The Great Marbach Debate: Is the “Edgar” Haircut Fire or Foolish?

A Haircut Dividing San Antonio — One Fade at a Time

If you’ve driven down Marbach Road lately, you’ve probably seen it — the sharp line, the bold shape, the unmistakable Edgar haircut (or as locals call it, “the Marbach.”) Some say it’s the hottest look in San Antonio. Others say… it’s the modern mullet. 👀

But love it or hate it, one thing’s for sure — the Edgar is a vibe.

A Brief History of Haircuts That Made Us Laugh Later

Let’s be honest — every generation has that haircut.
The ’80s had the mullet, the ’90s gave us frosted tips, and the 2000s were all about emo bangs covering one eye. We look back, we laugh, but at the time — we thought we looked amazing.

So maybe the Marbach Edgar is just this decade’s signature style — bold, confident, and unapologetically local.

Why the Edgar Works (And Why It Doesn’t)

Let’s break it down — because even funny haircuts deserve a fair trial.

🔥 Why It Works:

• Clean, sharp lines — the fade game is serious.

• Shows personality — confident, no apologies.

• Pairs perfectly with a fade and fresh sneakers.

💀 Why It Doesn’t (According to Your Tía):

• The shape can be… intense.

• Hard to pull off if your head shape isn’t built for it.

• You might get mistaken for an alpaca meme. (Sorry, we had to.)

The Style of the Streets

The Marbach haircut isn’t just a look — it’s a San Antonio cultural moment.
It’s seen at the bus stop, the barbershop, the high school hallway, and everywhere in between. It’s a mix of pride, humor, and confidence that screams, “I’m from the West Side — and I’m owning it.”

At Shear Illusions Hair Studio, we’ve seen every style come and go — from perms to pixie cuts. And whether you’re team Edgar or team “please make it stop,” we celebrate every look that makes San Antonio what it is: bold, unique, and full of personality.

So… What Do You Think?

We want to hear from YOU!
👉 Is the Edgar haircut 🔥 or 💀?
👉 Would you ever try it?
👉 Do you think it’ll still be cool in 10 years, or will it join the mullet in the Haircut Hall of Fame?

Drop your opinion below, tag your friends, and let’s settle this once and for all! 💬
Because on the West Side, we don’t just follow trends — we start them.